.
As I have been at home unable to do much of anything for the past 3 days, I have resorted to reliving Olympic figure skating -- scouring NBC's poorly designed website for replays of the pairs short & free and the mens short & free programs. Now, it may be because I'm an elitist fan who (at ONE point, at least) could name every jump by sight and all of the major players on the chess board... but I've been feeling
let down by figure skating recently. I'm particularly disappointed in the mens short program results.
Here's what I've seen, starting with 6th place:
Johnny Weir: What a performer! This guy is a ham & a half and was absolutely adorable on the ice. He's got good speed and covers the ice well, including covering lots of ice with his jumps. Beautiful artistry, definitely gets the crowd involved. Also, I think his choreography was some of the most excellently matched to his music. His hits, his jumps, his arm positions, even his flying camel were perfectly timed to the sound -- unlike some of the other guys in the competition. Downsides: Ummm??? I'm not sure. Apparently, he "doesn't have transitions" but I call shenanigans on that, as did the crowd in Vancouver. They were NOT liking the judges after his scores, and neither was I. He may have been cheated out of the 5th place spot.
Stephane Lambiel: Hands down the best spinner of the pack, IMO. His body positions during his spins, his speed, and his ability to keep rotating over the same patch of ice were beautiful to watch. I seriously think that some of the other guys should take note and spice up their spinning. It got a little old to see the same position over and over again. Lambiel made the spins stand out. He also had a rather nice 2nd half to his program. That being said, I just don't think he opened strong. The first part of his program was just bleh, and he didn't have the same popping energy that the other top guys have. For this reason, I'm not sure he should've placed above Weir, who seemed to have more speed and artistry than Lambiel.
Oda Nobunari: I don't agree with this placing
at all. This guy had energy to spare, but I think I'm biased by how little I enjoyed his music. Technically, there were no major errors and he did have massive, enduring energy, but the program just didn't convince me of itself. I feel like he's just too "young" on the ice.
Daisuke Takahashi:
Awesome! Great costume, great artistry, great technique, good choreography... Like Johnny, this guy got the crowd going, never let up, and absolutely sold his short program for every cent it was worth. Even his footwork passes were more than a check next to a requirement; they were downright enjoyable. I'm not sure that Lysacek should have ranked above him at all. To be honest, I'm not sure Plushenko should've either. Just watch Takahashi and you'll have fun... something that you can't necessarily say about the top two.
Evan Lysacek: Here is where I really start to get conflicted. Here's a guy with a very conservative, classic looking style. He's taller than the rest, so his lines are gorgeous to watch. His exits out of jumps are picture perfect. He also has good endurance and carries consistent energy throughout his program. His footwork passes are intricate and he carries tremendous speed throughout them (which isn't always the case). However, I'm totally not sold on his choreography... and if we're going to get on people about transitions, I'm definitely not sure that Lysacek has them any better than Weir does. He also doesn't have incredible spins.... or even an incredible flying camel. In fact, he doesn't have incredible height on his jumps either (although I may not fault him for that given his height). He's good... I'm just not sure that his short program was better than Takahashi's. I'm really not sure about that.
Evgeny Plushenko: This is my WTF? moment. What the
hell is this guy doing at the top? I felt like his choreography was
terrible for the piece he chose. His footwork was slow and boring, and he didn't seem to have transition
at all. I felt like he was a serious case of "connecting jumps," and, indeed, that's his specialty. He's the only guy in the world, apparently, who can do a quad axel in combination. I'm down, I think that's awesome, but I feel like he got into gold medal standing with that one trick. I'm
very annoyed that he's ranked above Takahashi & Lysacek. He's a technical master, but his artistry and choreography leave much to be desired as far as I'm concerned.
Having said all of that, I only have one thing to add... go back and look... just
look at Brian Boitano, Brian Orser, Kurt Browning, Elvis Stojko (the first guy to DO a quad in combination, btw) and Scott Hamilton... go back and look at their gold medal performances and tell me that they don't put most of the current guys to shame. Sure, they weren't stringing triple-triple combinations together, but they had
style. Kurt Browning and Brian Boitano, in particular. When I go back and watch Boitano's gold medal performance, it still gives me the chills... every last piece of footwork, every last detail (the raised arm for the opening triple jump), his toe touches, the AIR on his flying camels right into a sit spin.... the
theme of the soldier beautifully represented throughout the length of the whole program. It's sheer perfection. And while Plushenko might be sheer technical perfection, he doesn't move me the way Boitano used to. Takahashi and Lysacek
could, I think... but it remains to be seen what they'll pull out for the short program.
I'm kind of secretly hoping that they'll bring the goods so that Plushenko can taste a slice of humble pie... AND so that I can see some good
and beautiful figure skating... please.
.